All posts

investing

Direct vs regular mutual funds: the 1% that costs lakhs

Same fund, same manager, same portfolio — but one pays a commission out of your returns every year, forever. Over a long SIP that compounds.

6 min readBy Nilay Kabariya · how we check this

Here's a fact that quietly costs Indian investors thousands of crores a year: every mutual fund comes in two versions — 'regular' and 'direct' — identical in every way except one. The regular plan pays a commission to the distributor who sold it to you, out of YOUR returns, every single year for as long as you hold it. The direct plan doesn't. Same fund, same manager, same stocks; one just skips the middleman's cut.

How big is the difference?

The commission shows up as a higher expense ratio — typically 0.5% to 1.2% more a year on a regular plan than the direct version of the same fund. That sounds tiny. It isn't, because it compounds against you. On a ₹10,000/month SIP over 25 years, a 1% higher expense ratio can cost you ₹20–30 lakh in final corpus — money that went to a distributor, not to you.

SIP Calculator

Why regular plans still dominate

Because they're SOLD, and direct plans have to be BOUGHT. Banks, apps and agents earn that trailing commission, so they steer you to regular plans by default — often without you realising there was a choice. If you invested through a bank relationship manager, a traditional agent, or many 'free' apps, you're very likely in regular plans right now.

How to switch to direct

Buy direct plans through the AMC's own website, or a genuinely direct platform (many charge a flat fee instead of a commission). To move existing regular holdings, switch them to the direct version of the same fund — but note that a switch counts as a redemption for tax and may trigger capital gains and exit load, so check the numbers and time it first.

Step-up SIP Calculator

When regular plans are worth it

Honestly: if a good, fee-conscious advisor is actively guiding your whole financial plan and the commission is how they're paid, that guidance can be worth the cost for someone who'd otherwise make expensive mistakes. But if all you got was 'sign here' and no ongoing advice, you're paying an advice fee for no advice.

Direct and regular are the same fund with a different price tag — and the cheaper one is the one that doesn't quietly skim your returns for decades. Check whether your funds say 'Direct' or 'Regular' (it's printed right in the fund name), and if they're regular with no advice attached, switching is one of the simplest lakhs-saving moves in personal finance.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between direct and regular mutual funds?
They're the same fund with the same portfolio and manager. A regular plan pays a commission to the distributor who sold it, baked into a higher expense ratio (typically 0.5–1.2% more a year). A direct plan cuts out that commission, so more of your return stays with you.
How much does a regular plan cost over time?
The extra ~1% a year compounds. On a ₹10,000/month SIP over 25 years, the higher expense ratio of a regular plan can cost roughly ₹20–30 lakh in final corpus versus the direct version of the same fund.
How do I switch from regular to direct?
Buy the direct version through the AMC's website or a flat-fee direct platform, and switch existing regular holdings to the direct plan of the same fund. A switch counts as a redemption for tax, so check capital gains and any exit load before doing it.

Educational content, not financial advice. Figures are illustrative and based on the rules current at the time of writing; verify specifics with a qualified advisor.

Free tools to try

Play · Market Racers

Learn to trade by playing — free

Reading is a start; feeling it sticks. Market Racers is a free trading game: read a live chart, protect each trade with a stop-loss, and race four rated rivals. Play money, no signup.

Play Market Racers

Keep reading